Deliverance
We humans with our celebrated advantage of reason must also endure reason’s dark side: cognitive dissonance. When things aren’t as we think they should be, one way or another we must reconcile the difference to maintain our sanity. Consonance must triumph over dissonance even if we must fool ourselves to get there. Harmony must supplant cacophony. Otherwise, we can become very grumpy. In the extreme, neurotic.
In the last now twenty-plus years, since the ill-founded and clumsily executed War on Terror (2003), the Great Recession (2008), the Covid Pandemic (2020), and the hyper-destructive presidency of Donald Trump, our collective dissonance in America has risen to levels that have produced the highest levels of mental health issues seen in American history. In 1964 the health crisis was declared by the Surgeon General as issues arising from smoking; in 2001, it was obesity; in 2021a mental health crisis was declared. We are clearly beyond grumpy.
After we tire of fear and anger, our next response is detachment. The ostrich is known to plunge their head in the sand; we humans check out. We withdraw from once reliable relationships with each other and, moreover, institutions that were once foundational to our well-being. Institutions that enjoyed our attention and even loyalty like organized religion, government, and the media have moved from a sense of advocacy to adversarial in nature.
Our flight from organized religion has been underway for twenty years now. The rise of what the PEW Research Center calls the “nones,” as in unaffiliated with any church or religion, reached its peak in the last few years. Organized religion, at its apex in the late twentieth century, became corrupted by televangelists, terrorists, and wayward priests, monks, and imams whose greed, depravities, and insatiable thirst for power repulsed followers as dissonance between the practices of those who led our religious institutions could not be reconciled with the teachings of Christ, the Buddha, Moses, or Muhammed. In the early twenty-first century in America, a crisis of faith became normative.
I won’t belabor the downfall of our federal government as a credible trustee of our public goods, although I suspect if our founders were with us today, they might call it a “self-evident truth.” And though we can point to Trump, or Congress, or the Supreme Court with our finger of blame, we should be mindful that in a democracy the people get the government they deserve. We need to look in the mirror on this one.
Our federal government was never designed to do what we ask of it, today. A walk through our founding documents, including the Federalist and Anti-federalist Papers discuss in great detail the issues we face today. Despite what most recall from Madison’s concern for “factions” (Federalist No. 10), more fundamentally we have allowed responsibility scope-creep to move an abundance of resources and authority from the local level to the national. We have over-delegated to the point of establishing a festering sense of endemic entitlement that is both irresponsible and toxic. This is our doing. Politicians like Trump are simply exploiting the mistakes we have made. We must unwind ourselves from this twisted dysfunctional reality.
In the pantheon of today’s pathetic institutions also belongs the media. The ethics of journalism have vanished together with our sense of virtues-based moral purpose. The days of Edward R. Murrow and Walter Cronkite have been relegated to the realm of nostalgia. The trolls—once a novelty of the early Internet—now dominate every aspect of traditional and online media. The desperation of attention-seekers has, as the chief troll, Steve Bannon, advocated, “flood[ed] the zone with shit.”
In organized religion and government and the media, we can no longer trust any information that emanates from these institutions. Our only available coping behavior it to tune out—to flee.
In his recent and final column for the New York Times, David Brooks wrote “We Americans went through hard times before, and we have always recovered through a process of cultural rupture and repair. Some old set of values and practices has to be torn away and some new ones embraced.” The process of detachment—of being “torn away”—is a necessary albeit painful step in achieving deliverance and establishing a new harmony in the world.
In America, perhaps more so than many places in the world, we have entered into a malaise of nihilism—devoid of inspiration and conviction wrapped around a pole of pessimism where trust is as rare as tanzanite. America is a once great superpower withering at its own hand. It is what one might call an “epic fail,” but also completely necessary as a precursor to deliverance and entirely consistent with the fate of empires throughout history. There is no rise without a fall. There is no liberation without despair. We must embrace and suffer the reality of creative destruction to affect renewal and rebirth as the next America.
Further, we must take the basic responsibility of questioning everything—all the givens as well as what are now obsolete norms. Taking responsibility starts with a commitment to a sense of moral purpose where respect and dignity return to the altar of community. Eventually, one good deed or act of kindness at a time, we can build a new society. One where we first hold ourselves to account, while we embrace each other. This is the only path to a better tomorrow. Pain, liberation, deliverance, and renewal.
Our most important institutions have collapsed. Waiting around and hoping they somehow revive themselves without us is foolish. It isn’t going to happen. Those in power have no interest in being displaced; they will hold onto their power with a death-grip while hoping we remain cowered and on the sidelines.
How we each respond to this challenge is a personal choice. Disengaging to the point of detachment is necessary today. It is an act of cleansing; both purifying and clarifying. Then, pick your time and place to re-engage—always on your own terms in a manner that is consistent with your particular and personal sense of purpose.
America is our country. We have allowed it to be hijacked by politicians who masquerade as Christians and patriots. Everything about the future is determined by the choices we make in the present. As the saying goes, “to each his own”; but, we must indeed own.









